Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I don't see any indication that NetFoundry zrok supports end-to-end encryption from the client to the web server. The default configuration definitely terminates SSL on NetFoundry's server, and I don't see any documentation for how to avoid that. There's a TCP tunneling mode, but servers that use this mode can only be accessed by clients that are themselves also connected to the NetFoundry VPN service, not by clients on the public web. What's needed is a TLS tunneling mode that figures out the correct target via SNI, and zrok doesn't seem to provide that.


You are correct, zrok doesn't support mutual TLS. zrok is the free offering that NetFoundry supports so it's easy to see why you looked there for information.

The productized version, NetFoundry Frontdoor (doc here https://netfoundry.io/docs/frontdoor/how-to-guides/create-mt...) is what offers mutual TLS support.

It'll still terminate TLS at the servers, though. It's not mTLS all the way through to the endpoint.


    > It'll still terminate TLS at the servers, though. It's not mTLS all the way 
    > through to the endpoint.
That was the entire point, though. If NetFoundry Frontdoor can see the traffic (because it gets terminated on their servers, mTLS or not), then it's not end-to-end encrypted as the parent commenter claimed.


I think the issue is zrok vs. NetFoundry/OpenZiti. Zrok is the easy button to project a public endpoint from inside a network. It is not encrypted all the way through, as it is a proxy solution. NetFoundry/OpenZiti provides methods to provide tunnels all the way through. NetFoundry is a company, OpenZiti is a FOSS project/technology sponsored by NetFoundry, and zrok is a product of NetFoundry built on OpenZiti tech, so it is easy to cross things up. I think the comment was in regard to NetFoundry/OpenZiti, while your response referenced zrok. The list above has both.


i should have been more clear - you have the option:

+ e2ee via netfoundry's zero trust products

+ non-e2ee via netfoundry frontdoor




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: