Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | matheusmoreira's commentslogin

Yep. People are paying for the privilege of segmenting themselves into the high disposable income categories of the market. They're paying to do the corporation's market segmentation for them.

Yeah. Only way to avoid becoming the product is to become a "pirate" instead. Pretty sad but it is what it is.

Thers no ads on the high seas?

I've seen ads of several varieties:

- Public websites are chock full of ads

- Downloading a file often means hopping through several redirects (each of which is an ad) and sometimes even having to "complete an offer" to get the final link

- Private websites have some affiliate deal with VPN providers. "We did the research, this one is the best, if you subscribe through this link you will get some perks on our website".

Of all the kinds of ads out there, that last one is the least objectionable to me. They don't force it on you, it doesn't clog up the important parts of the site, and they supposedly do some research to pick the best provider to affiliate with. I "never" click on ads but this one worked on me.


Why are you doing it that way? That's the hardest way to get content and most likely to infect you along the way. Just torrent stuff.

Torrent is what I meant by public/private website, I didn’t want to spell it out in case someone got offended. I rarely use direct file download but for the odd mp3, console firmware/keys, etc it can be easier to grab exactly what I want.

If you can get a private tracker or sonarr running, pretty much no ads.

Not until that asshat company wanting to deploy satellite constellation that displays ads from space. It's not like there are billboards in the middle of the ocean

That was a stretch, really had to jam that little dig in there, huh?

Although if they did somehow deploy their constellation as a legible ad, I wouldn't even complain. "Drink Coke" spelled out with a hundred satellites would be hilarious.


What dig?


They don't break encryption, they circumvent it. They get into people's computers and access the stored data after it's been decrypted. They stockpile zero day vulnerabilities and use them against their targets in order to install persistent malware. They intercept equipment and literally implant hardware onto the PCBs that let them access the networks. They have access to hordes of government CCTVs. They have real time satellite imaging. They have cellphone tower data.

They don't break encryption, they circumvent it.

To quote a former Chief Scientist of the NSA, Rule #1 of cryptanalysis is "look for plaintext". Implementation flaws are very common.


This is all in line with significantly degraded collection capabilities.

They can easily go after specific targets, but bulk collection is no longer viable in the same way it was pre-Snowden.


Yes but I wouldn't say their capabilities have been "greatly" degraded. It's still very much in the "push a button and have someone's entire life history up on the screen" territory.

Degraded would be "it is impossible for them to know anything about people unless they send dozens of human agents to stalk them".


I think going from "lol we can read and store all the emails sent by everybody" to "lol we can hack any specific person and then read their emails" indicates a massive loss of capability.

The first approach enabled them to find targets that were not on their radar based on message contents, they can no longer do that.


They still read emails. No doubt they're inside Google, Microsoft, Apple. They might not be inside Proton Mail, it uses PGP but keys are stored server side so I wouldn't know.

No doubt they still read texts. I think the US is still among the countries that use SMS a lot.

They no doubt have access to the data big tech's mined out of the entire world's population. That capability alone puts them into "bring everything about this guy up on the screen" territory.


>They still read emails. No doubt they're inside Google, Microsoft, Apple. They might not be inside Proton Mail, it uses PGP but keys are stored server side so I wouldn't know.

I don't doubt for a second that they can read specific emails, but to suggest that they have bulk collection capabilities within Google or Microsoft is a stretch. NSA lacks the legal authority to compel that, NSA lacks the money to bribe Google or Microsoft and NSA likely lacks the political backing to put the biggest US companies in such a compromised position.

>I think the US is still among the countries that use SMS a lot.

Sure, but that's increasingly iMessage.


The NSA lacked legal authority to do this bulk collection prior to the Snowden leaks, and yet that didn't stop them from collecting. Why would I believe that their lack of legal authority today would stop them?

Because it's not possible for them to get the same easy access anymore?

It was certainly easy in a world where everything wasn't encrypted, that's not the case anymore.


In case anyone wants to actually get into this, cyberdeck development communities are a good place to start.

https://youtu.be/o00P7wHbd2c

https://youtu.be/2VDRO9jjZzo

Really fun stuff if you have the necessary electronics knowledge!


This is an absolutely vital development for our computing freedom. Billion dollar industrial fabs are single points of failure, they can be regulated, subverted, enshittified by market forces. We need the ability to make our own hardware at home, just like we can make our own freedom respecting software at home.

This isn't just awesome, this is world changing. Fabricating our own hardware at home is the hardware equivalent of writing our own free software at home. This will help ensure our long term computing freedom.

Personally I agree, but the world doesn't seem to. Their first project (https://sam.zeloof.xyz/first-ic/) was all the way back in 2018, and it doesn't seem like it changed all too much (yet), while since I read the first blog post in 2018, I also thought we would have reached a much more mature DIY ecosystem by now.

Don't get me wrong, I'm excited too about it, and can't wait to personally do some experiments as well, although not at the same scale. But I'm not sure it's world changing, at least until I've actually seen any changes :)


Finicky chemicals and relatively expensive equipment. But he’s founded a company with Jim Keller. We occasionally see them post a photo with zero context, but we do know some things. Like they are targeting lots volume stuff and basically building fab equipment. But not much more.

It's really amazing, great work! And please keep sharing progress and, if you want, how can other people follow on your footsteps!

It's not my work!

https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2019/06/felony-contempt-busine...

It's not your phone, it's theirs. They're just letting you use it, and only if you're a good boy who follows all their policies and terms and conditions. Subvert this in any way and it's a felony.


> Hardware attestation needs to be an antitrust violation

Yes!! Absolutely agree. This needs to be made illegal.


> My guess is that modern hardware is too complicated for one hacker to write reliable drivers.

Modern hardware has turned our operating systems into isolated "user OS" nodes in the schematics, completely sandboxed away from the real action. Our operating systems don't really operate systems anymore.

https://youtu.be/36myc8wQhLo


Excellent and scary video that I share myself all the time.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: