Well, to my mind you seem too hasty to conclude it's false. Sure, statistically there is a very small non-negligible chance that exactly one person will survive, but realization of an unlikely event is no short of a miracle. To conclude that it happened randomly seems as naive as to conclude it happened purposefully. If your guts tells you it was a random event that is just fine, but be aware it is a metaphysical axiom of yours
Certainly nothing can ever be conclusively proven. I might be a brain in a vat that has had a fictional reality fed to me for my entire life. Such arguments may be interesting in some venues, but is HN really that venue?
> To conclude that it happened randomly seems as naive as to conclude it happened purposefully.
I strongly disagree. You aren't saying that both outcomes are possible (I'd agree with that), but they are equally likely, a much, much stronger claim. The sun might go on shining tomorrow, or it might collapse due to some unforeseen physical process. Both have non-zero probabilities, but it is the person who claims they are equally likely who is the naive one.
As for not defined so let's interpret "miracle" to mean highly unlikely events, they happen millions of times day, and we rarely notice. The bill I received in tender has the serial number MF53610716D. What are the odds of that? If you limit "miracle" to be highly unlikely events that most people would also notice, it would be strange if they weren't happening all the time. Every person who wins a lottery (and there are thousands every day), the person who is told by their doctor their cancer is terminal but then it goes into remission has a "miracle", the guy who loses his job and is about to be evicted then gets a job callback for an application he sent in months ago and forgot about experiences a "miracle."
