> If its possible to be a profitable independent day trader, and we know it is because many are
You're forgetting about the many that aren't profitable. You're also forgetting about the majority that are less profitable than the market average. The latter is probably the easiest to overlook. Yes, they are technically profitable, but so are packaged portfolios of stock held for long periods of time. If you can't be more profitable than someone who puts in zero effort, then whats the point of putting in more work?
You're forgetting about the many that aren't profitable. You're also forgetting about the majority that are less profitable than the market average. The latter is probably the easiest to overlook. Yes, they are technically profitable, but so are packaged portfolios of stock held for long periods of time. If you can't be more profitable than someone who puts in zero effort, then whats the point of putting in more work?