Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Boot speed is a big selling point for Docker, but Docker's isolation story is poorer than a VM. If you can make a VM boot as quickly as Docker while preserving isolation, then Docker loses a big selling point.


It’s called Zones (on illumos, prev. on Solaris)


I'm a huge fan of Illumos and SmartOS and think that Zones + LX Branding are a far superior technology than the hodgepodge of cgroups + namespaces + userland container technology. HOWEVER---the amount of driver support in the OpenSolaris forks, the awful package management system, the ancient IPF system etcetera make it a non-starter for most environments. I have used SmartOS in production (along with the Triton ecosystem) and found it to be well thought out and compelling, albeit woefully immature and buggy.

I think that these reasons, plus the EOL nature of Solaris "upstream", would easily put off most people in charge of making a long term technology commitment. I know it did for me.


Well, you are right, but remember how old SmartOS actually is... I kinda hope more people get it, and start investing into that amazing open source technology. I always liked BSDs and Solaris more than Linux (who I find really messy and chaotic).


Solaris as an upstream was dead long ago; Oracle stopped publishing source years before killing their own product. The heirs of opensolaris seem to have managed well enough




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: