Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> But we still pay migrant workers to harvest fruit

Harvesting fruit is far more complex than driving. It's a 3D search through a complex space.

> Driving a car under non-ideal conditions is incredibly complex, and relies upon human communication.

No it doesn't. The rules of the road detail precisely how cars interact with each other and with pedestrians.

> We humans currently manage about one death per hundred million miles; Uber made it all of two million.

Incorrect use of statistics.



> Harvesting fruit is far more complex than driving. It's a 3D search through a complex space.

Are you making a joke? "a 3D search [for a path that reaches the destination safely and legally] through complex space" is exactly how I would describe driving. (Also, driving is an online problem.)


Cars don't leave the road which is a 2D surface. In what way is that a 3D problem?


Ever heard of an elevated highway, ramp, flying junction, bridge, or tunnel?

I mean, yeah the topology is not as complex as a pure unrestricted 3d space but it's also more complex than pure 2d space. It's a search through a space, and it's complex, I don't know if nitpicking about the topology adds a lot here?


That's still 2D space. A car simply can't move along the z axis, so the fact that the road itself moves in 3 dimensions is irrelevant.

Even navigational paths that consider all of the junctions, ramps, etc. are simply reduced to a weighted graph with no notion of any dimensions beyond forward and backwards.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: