Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Gerrymandering doesn't affect votes, it just affects how they're counted.

No, gerrymandering doesn't affect the raw number of votes for each candidate, but it undeniably affects the outcome of elections.

> it's because a majority of the people in that state have voted for that party.

That's not true, because of the affect gerrymandering can have.



>No, gerrymandering doesn't affect the raw number of votes for each candidate, but it undeniably affects the outcome of elections.

Oh, absolutely. But still, if Party X has a majority in the legislature, that still means that a very, very large number of your fellow citizens (possibly not an outright majority, depending on just how the gerrymandering worked out, but probably still very close to a majority) voted for Party X.

Another thing to note is that gerrymandering does not affect all elections. For a state, gerrymandering has zero effect on the governor's election, since all votes are counted equally in that race. So Wisconsinites are entirely to blame for their choice of their governor.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: