Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

And I suspect that both of you got technical degrees and work in technical fields.

You are almost by definition an edge case.



Are technical fields really an edge case?

I suspect going to a university is helpful in most STEM related fields. In anything medical or law related you don't even have to think about getting a job without a degree. I don't see how anyone can compensate an economical or business study by doing project on their own.

If anything I think IT is an outlier, because not going to university and learning the subjects you would have been taught on your own might be a valid option.


I was commenting to the argument that college teaches nothing useful.

Law and medicine are the poster child for credentialism, you are forced by law to complete the degree to work, even if most law and medical professionals will tell you, work has nothing to do with college.

They suffer the “driving license problem”, having the title says nothing about your competence.

For instance, pretty much everyone has to study trigonometry, but very little people actually need to know trigonometry to do their job. In that sense technical fields are an outlier, because knowing trigonometry actually matters to your career.


I can't speak for lawyers, but MD education is very relevant. Maybe other MDs can chime in, but at least once a week in practice I use something I learned once in medical school (which was a LONG time ago :) ). Now a 4-year undergraduate education could have been trimmed to ~2-3 years i'd say.


Not at HN, where this is discussed, and also not considering that the article being discussed is hosted on a github page.


An outlier in terms of the people who go to college


I believe most degrees are awarded in STEM, with biology above all as the most awarded degree. Not much of an edge case.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: