Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You think it doesn't?


Well there was the 'flash crash' but it wasn't that big a deal. This financially uninformed hacker thinks it could get much worse some day soon.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2010_Flash_Crash


It won't, because although computers have a lot of control over the market, people also look at it pretty regularly. The reason why nobody noticed a $23,000,000 book on Amazon is because out-of-print biology books are not very liquid. If that were Microsoft stock, someone would have manually made a bet on it, and then the price would have corrected after a while.


No. If someone were asking $23m for a share of MSFT it would just be way outside the market and would just sit there. Plenty of people leave way outside the market bids and asks just in case someone else makes an accidental huge market order.


"It won't, because although computers have a lot of control over the market, people also look at it pretty regularly"

The problem is a vast number of transactions, and huge price moves, can happen in literally the blink of an eye.


So what? If you're a value investor, it's not your problem. The price is not going to stay wrong for very long.

The only people that will have problems are people who are heavily-leveraged and have no hedge.


True, but at the same time, we're talking about billions of dollars of real money. In clear self interest, all those institutions will have built obvious checks in their system. Losing several billions of dollars in seconds is something they want to avoid.

Indeed, the fact that the flash crash was the definition of something with a vast number of transactions, huge price moves, and happened in the blink of an eye but still was relatively minor and almost inconsequential shows the reliance of the stock market.


It was inconsequential largely because most of the wonky trades were voided.


There are also obscure stocks that not many people look at.


Obscure stocks can't have much impact on the stock market as a whole by definition.


What is your point? The books in question were also obscure.


Yes, and their impact on Amazon as a whole was nil. JonnieCache was claiming it could get worse than the flash crash.

For the record, I personally think it could, but not due to bugs in pricing obscure stocks.


And they didn't have much impact on the book market.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: