Would creating a ZFS snapshot, then either copying from that snapshot or sending it to another machine with zfs send, also be reliable? IIUC, ZFS snapshots are point-in-time consistent.
Beat me to mentioning this. Rsync is not a safe database backup tool. Period. It can be used to move around backups created by whatever specific database tool generated them, but just blindly using rsync is a recipe for unrecoverable corruption