Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Probably not true, but only just. 570 men die of breast cancer each year in the US (latest stats from the Cancer Statistics Center) while 330 people have died in mass shootings in the US this year so far. You can see the stats, taken from the Gun Violence Archive, here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1xB5VWgcpvw5UrWYq-6so...


Mass shootings are more traumatic though as they're extremely brutal, graphic, and sudden. I'd weight the actual impact of someone I know being shot in a mass shooting far worse than someone I know dying of breast cancer. The latter won't have them leave in the morning and not come back at 5pm randomly. It also won't create a general climate of fear, distrust between people, and terrible politics. Both are tragic, but tragedies of different kind, which is why direct comparisons always seem technically correct but missing so badly the way people actually think about and experience tragedy.


> also won't create a general climate of fear, distrust between people, and terrible politics

Also why they're allowed to continue. "It's good for business."


I personally know people who were injured in a mass shooting. It sends shockwaves throughout the surrounding community in a way many crimes do not.


Not debating any of that; originally thought the comment above mine was wrong, looked at the stats, and found they were far closer than I assumed.


That document says 330 people died from mass shootings.

I was comparing males who died from breast cancer to males who died from mass shootings.

I’m also a bit confused … your stats show more males dying from breast cancer than people dying from mass shootings.

Doesn’t that support my position? Did one of us misspeak?




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: