Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

That's a good observation!

I get unreasonably irked when some subreddit won't let me post a comment / removes a comment. Like, "who do you think you are to limit my ability to express myself here?!" Deprived of context, my contribution is meaningless -- so, how does that interact with the freedom of speech, really?

Say I'm in a crowded square where people are arguing about squids, and I have a squid-related revelation I'd like to share, but the self-appointed Guardians of the Square have gagged me. Is this an infringement on free speech? I'm free to leave the square and speak -- but what I have to say is relevant within the confines of the square, not elsewhere.



It'd be weird and very abusable if free speech ever implied the right to a venue.

If they couldn't stop people talking at their venue what's to stop someone completely sabotaging their agenda?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: