Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Hate to break it to you, but ISS is not technically in space. There is still some athmosphere

There's still some atmosphere quite high away from Earth, the transition from "not space" to "space" is asymptotic.

> a ton of gravity (comparing to "actual space")

It doesn't matter because ISS is in orbit. Weightlessness is weightlessness, whether you're free-falling in circles, straight at something, or so far away from anything it's hard to calculate who's pulling on you the most.

> plenty of protection from the earth's magnetic shield

Fair enough.

But I reserve my right to hold ISS as being in space, to counterbalance the parent's claim: "We already know about the realities of space colonization: it’s not possible.".



>There's still some atmosphere quite high away from Earth, the transition from "not space" to "space" is asymptotic.

Not saying otherwise; however, 400km above surface and eg. Stationary orbit are quite different things.

>It doesn't matter because ISS is in orbit. Weightlessness is weightlessness, whether you're free-falling in circles, straight at something, or so far away from anything it's hard to calculate who's pulling on you the most.

Actually, we don't know that. From a perception perspective, you are right;From a biological perspective, we actually don't know if there is any biological process that may be affected by the free-falling effect, specifically.

>"We already know about the realities of space colonization: it’s not possible."

The op's assertion seems to be right - most of what we know to date seems to confirm it. Maybe "not possible" is a strong statement, but certainly not feasible, and that is not going to change anytime soon.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: