Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

PP phrases it badly, but there is an aspect of scientific truth in there.

Your chances of getting PTSD from a traumatic experience is less if you feel as if you are in control.

I cannot find the paper I read at the time, I feel I'm missing the right phrase, but here's a more recent one: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6161595/

---

I have had three memorable traumatic events in a fairly long life, each about ten years apart.

I was in an explosion where my girlfriend and I were the closest people to survive; I was in a physically abusive relationship; and I was in an abusive work situation.

I had no effects from the explosion. It took me over a year to recover from the abusive relationship and separately, from the abusive job.

A counselor explained to me the reason was that after the explosion, I was in control and immediately made the right decisions to survive basically unscratched, so I experienced no trauma. In the other two cases, I was trapped and felt powerless.



Thank you for sharing your own similar experience and understanding me.

It's difficult for me to explain abuse without being stifled, but I have a feeling while everyone online talks about telling you to stop victim blaming, the abused one is victim blaming themselves anyway. It's why it's so traumatic, I replayed the situation to make sense of it, and it hurt every time, until I got out of that mental rut.

It's funny, when bad things happen I dismiss other problems I had because I had a worst one before so it helped with stresses.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: