I can't see it this way. The recent leak was entirely due to the redis-py bug. Any other company that used redis-py together with asyncio would have had the same leak (and this is fixed already), but, for some reason, only ChatGPT is being punished. Also, short of running all third-party source code through expensive auditors and insurance companies, there was no way to prevent or mitigate this.

If they continue to enforce this without also making all liability-limitation clauses in software licenses invalid (and thus killing non-commercial software, including OSS), I would treat this as something very hypocritical.