Sorry. Not even close. Source: I actually studied Phisolophy/Logic at Uni. Good try though.
Also, your aircraft example is absolutely ridiculous.
This isn't an appeal to purity at all. This is about domain knowledge and experience.
A more appropriate example might be the contrast between someone who has only done 3D printing now deciding to design and make parts meant for CNC machining. The lack of expertise and understanding will result in some pretty serious problem.
Another example, this time about software development. I have over ten years of professional software development using Forth. Someone coming to Forth from, say, Python, is likely to make an mess until they understand how to approach problems in Forth. I also have about ten years professional coding experience using APL. Same thing. Someone coming to APL from other languages is going to run into problems until they gain enough knowledge to write APL.
Sorry. Not even close. Source: I actually studied Phisolophy/Logic at Uni. Good try though.
Also, your aircraft example is absolutely ridiculous.
This isn't an appeal to purity at all. This is about domain knowledge and experience.
A more appropriate example might be the contrast between someone who has only done 3D printing now deciding to design and make parts meant for CNC machining. The lack of expertise and understanding will result in some pretty serious problem.
Another example, this time about software development. I have over ten years of professional software development using Forth. Someone coming to Forth from, say, Python, is likely to make an mess until they understand how to approach problems in Forth. I also have about ten years professional coding experience using APL. Same thing. Someone coming to APL from other languages is going to run into problems until they gain enough knowledge to write APL.