Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> We have global identities-- IPv4/6 address. v6 moreso than v4.

Nope. My identity, as a concept, doesn't change if I'm at Burger King, Starbucks, at home, or at work, or if I'm using a cell phone, or my Sister's computer.

Emails are the closest thing we have to a proper global identity. But it wasn't enough in practice. Reddit gives us a "Reddit" identity across a huge number of subcommunities.

Tumblr, MySpace, Xanga, Discord, Twitter, Facebook... the primary "killer app" that all of these give us is this identity.

Emails are insufficient, because a spammer can create any email address they want, and there's no way for us to share which email addresses are spam with other "allies" on the internet.



Agreed.

Of course, emails are also insufficient because people don't want to use them as their identifier across sites which is why your account email is private on every social platform and only used for internal notifications and forgot-my-password.

People don't want a global identifier that connects every utterance they have across the internet with the same identifier they, for example, send job applications from.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: