Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Worrying about the security of curl | bash when talking about an operating system where the modus operandi for installing software was downloading closed-source and often obfuscated binaries from random websites and running them is insane.


Honestly, I feel like more people have been infected with malware from App Stores than from downloading and executing shit from random websites. Even Warez sites from back in the day were more trustworthy.

Cuz if you download from a random site, you might think twice about what it is, is the source trustworthy, etc? But the App Store, well Apple and Google tell me it's 100% safe, so just download all kinds of trash.


For mobile app stores you are right, but only because they are the ONLY place most people will obtain software for their device from. You don't download binaries and install them from web sites on Android or Apple.

For desktop operating systems, I think you are probably wrong. Downloading and installing binaries from web sites is a huge cause of malware infection. And warez sites were not trustworthy at any time.

I doubt much malware has been installed via Linux package managers or by the Windows app store (if anyone actually uses that).


Browser extension 'stores' are terrible too. Both Google's and Mozilla's.

On the other hand, I do trust F-Droid. The vetting of ideological motivated volunteers beats the vetting of disinterested corporations.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: