Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Trudeau obviously grasping at the chance of winning over some Sikh votes. Whether the allegations are credible or not is irrelevant to him, and likely will not be found out until after elections anyway.

On the other hand, Facebook is much more likely to err on the side of India given the much larger population and associated $ potential and THE BILL.

Canada is not exactly an espionage expert relative to places like India so I find it highly unlikely that we (Canada) will be able to figure this out in the short term without external help.



The Canadian government worked with US intelligence on this matter:

https://www.reuters.com/world/americas/canada-worked-closely...


Sikhs make up <2% of Canada. Even less when you account for that fact that not all of them are of age to vote. Do you really think a PM of Canada would throw away relationship with a potentially large trading partner for a few thousand votes?


This <2% population are not uniformly distributed.

And identity politics can and do win you seats in local councils, senates, congresses, and so on.

This is the very common mistake by identity politics deniers. They always say that <minority group> population is x% where x << 100. But what they forget, willingly or unwillingly, is that population is not uniformly distributed over the country and are concentrated in some parts, and a party, by appeasing the <minority> can and do win seats in democratic elections.

I have seen this first hand in multiple places.

Edit: I just learned that Trudeau's party is in power because of the support of a Shikh party. His party was 10 seats short of majority needed to form government. A Shikh party provided the support which put him in power.


>A Shikh party

wtf? NDP is led by Jagmeet Singh, who happens to be Sikh. That doesn't make NDP Sikh. What a ridiculous line of thought.


Jagmeet Singh has strong ties to Khalistani leaders [0].

[0]: https://capforcanada.com/air-india-bombing-revisited-sikhism...


and that makes NDP Sikh how?


Are you Canadian? Even asking the question feels ridiculous: yes, absolutely.

He shredded the Charter to fabricate a wedge (interior vaccine passports, firing civil servants) to win a few votes in the last election. This is absolutely in character.. good governance means nothing to Trudeau compared to being re-elected.


There could be more to it than just acquiring future votes for the Liberal Party.

Keep in mind that Jagmeet Singh is the leader of the NDP, the other main leftist party in Canada, and he represents the Burnaby South riding.

Due to how Canada's elections work, the Liberals drawing even a relatively small number of voters away from the NDP in key ridings could have a significant negative impact on the NDP's and Singh's level of success during the next election.

In 2021, Singh beat the Liberal candidate by only about 4,000 votes, for example. That was only 10% of the vote, and the overall turnout was merely 51% in that riding.


Trudeau reported what CSIS - in conjunction with it's allies - has concluded.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: