Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Interesting product, but the site has one of the worst GDPR controls ive seen - silently redirects to Google if you attempt to view the site from an EU IP address. Thought my computer is going nuts


Not just EU, Switzerland too.

That tells me everything I need to know, the site owner simply wants to steal my personal data and use it against me.


Surely that’s the reason and not the EU penalty for simply storing cookies “without consent” being so severe as to practically negate the value of EU citizens on the internet.


Cookies needed for a functional site can be used without notice.

The permission popups are only needed if you want to gather and store data. And why do that if you don't want to use it?

If you're really worried you can write a simple privacy policy stating your server stores some stuff like the client IP etc. (so you can do something like, block abuse) and then follow that policy to the letter by not doing anything else with the data you gather.

It's not hard.


Now imagine you don't give a shit about EU customers and just having to think of what our idiotic rules are is a waste of money. And all of this because I want to use google analytics and see how many people my landing page is getting? I would redirect us as well.

I did the same for VATMOSS when I was not in Europe: if I need to spend 5 days implementing VAT rules and collecting proof, I need to evaluate what I'll make from EU customers and if that's not likely to be significantly more than implementation cost you can all go and buy stuff somewhere else.

I just blame our idiot EU politicians for restricting freedom on the internet.


There's no reason for that site to use cookies in the first place.


At this point, isn't consent compliance a solved problem? That they can't find a canned solution to suit their needs is eyebrow-raising.


There's a lot more nuance to the GDPR. It's perfectly possible to use cookies and not need a banner. Our industry's use of banners is just a passive aggressive reaction to being told to respect our users.


It's also happening for Australian IP addresses, so it's unlikely to be GDPR related.


GDPR doesn't make it illegal to use cookies without consent.


Australia as well.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: