Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Not possible for any crime that is reported on by media, surely.


If its online newspapers then in EU we have the "right to be forgotten" which helps with those articles to be removed from search engines.


> which helps

Especially if you’re a corrupt politician, child abuser etc. it’s really helpful for that sort of people. Not so much for everyone else, but why would that ever be an issue?


I would think that, especially in a everything-online world, this is very useful for regular people. I for sure have removed some links to embarrassing posts I made as a teen, to which I've long lost account access to, to remove manually. And now with everybody's kids being on Tik Tok etc since very early age, I assume it will be used more and more.


If the law is written correct you sue any orinization that digs it up for libel. When those are won they will stop.


So newspapers will be afraid to report on things like that even when it clearly is in the in interest of the society for them to do that?

Criminal records don’t exist just to punish people and penalize them for the rest of their lives but also to inform other what those people are capable of. Expungement should only be possible for non-serious crimes and/or on a case by case basis


What crimes should be expunged, when it should be done, and how to do it are all debates worth having. There are lots of other details worth debating. However once the crime has been expunged it shouldn't be brought back again - that is the whole point: let people who have reformed get on with their life as best as possible.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: