Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Why would you give me any credit to any of Freuds ideas? Im honestly astonished the guy has any kind of credibility.


this is quite hyperbolic. he has too complicated a legacy to dismiss this easily. some of the concepts he pioneered include talk therapy, transference, significance of early childhood on psychological development, the influence of the unconscious on behavior - all of which we accept today


Was Freud really the first person to suggest talking to people about your problems can be therapeutic, or that the way you raise children affects them dramatically? As far as I am aware, the actual contents of the therapy he proposed, psychoanalysis, is complete bunk and no more effective than other forms of therapy.

I have a whole gripe with the "unconscious", unless all we mean by it is "past events affect who you are and affect your behavior" in which case I cant imagine Freud is the first person to have believed this.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: