Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> If the rabbit is injured, making noise and hoping for humans to help is a fools errand as the fox is more likely to hear and eat the rabbit.

> This is engrained in our evolution.

Literally the exact opposite?

> Recent research has also shown that the acoustic properties of human screams can be reliably detected within noisy environments, something presumably indicative of having evolved in noisy environments, such as dense forests, where there is a strong adaptive pressure to reliably signal danger (Nandwana et al., 2015).

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S014976341...

> Rabbit Basic Science: The only vocal sounds that are made are a loud high-pitched scream of terror or a range of growls and hums that denote pleasure or defence. Apprehensive or frightened rabbits will thump the ground with their hind feet. The loud thumping sounds acts as an alarm signal to other rabbits in the vicinity.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7158370/

> Screaming among rabbits indicates alarm associated with fear, pain, and psychological distress. Your rabbit may scream because it is scared of being attacked or dying. Rabbits also scream when they’re in excruciating pain, or when they’re having a seizure. …it is a sign of extreme pain, terror, or calling out for help.

https://www.rabbitcaretips.com/why-do-rabbits-scream/

> Lima beans release volatile chemical signals that are received by nearby plants of the same species when infested with spider mites. This 'message' allows the recipients to prepare themselves by activating defense genes, making them less vulnerable to attack, and also attracting another mite species that is a predator of spider mites (indirect defence).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alarm_signal

IMO "Dark Forest Theory"— The idea that (1) nobody would ever help anyone else and (2) nobody could ever understand anyone else because (3) we're all dumb forest animals capable of nothing higher than survival, so we may as well (a) hide and (b) kill anyone that tries to talk to us­— That probably says more about the people arguing for it, or about our own providence, than it does about any probable intestellar ecology.

> Humans become a rabbit, the malicious species a fox, the benevolent species humans.

In fact, if anything, using humans as the example of a benevolent society points out the absurdity of assuming that more technologically advanced polities must necessarily be malicious.

Killers don't prosper in civilized societies. And technologically advanced societies ruled by killers don't last long.



> that more technologically advanced polities must necessarily be malicious.

Europeans came to Africa, India and Americas with some better tech. How benevolent were europeans?


Relatively benevolent. They ended human sacrifice in the Americas and widow burning in India.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: