Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

[flagged]


People happy and proud of their work. What's wrong?


> given the very real concerns that there is a dangerous cult of personality surrounding Musk, seeing this footage presented this way is unsettling.


Seems like a very small-minded way to see things... But if it makes you feel any better, Musk is only one of many people working at SpaceX. You could see him as just a figurehead and you wouldn't too far from reality.


I could call you small minded for thinking only of advances in rocket technology, and ignoring the negative aspects of advancing Musk's power and influence. Should I?


>no u


This was a huge achievement and the workers were rightly cheering. I didn't take it as a sign of a cult of personality surrounding Musk at all.


The people who worked on this amazing effort are not allowed to cheer and be happy? What about spectators that gather like these employees to watch a launch from a distance? What about the ones who showed up for the space shuttle?

If you have followed SpaceX over the last 10-15 years, you’ll know that this is normal and is what makes the broadcasts fun to watch. The footage is high quality, with transparent telemetry, and multiple live views - unlike anything before or since. And the sheer joy of those employees is infectious.

What Musk, Shotwell, and the SpaceX team have achieved is truly astonishing and a massive win for humanity. I own no Tesla stock or cars, don’t use Starlink, and don’t use Twitter. But twisting this into something negative like this just does not make any sense to me. If anything, this comment shows the cult of (likely ideological) hatred towards Musk is more dangerous and unsettling than the alleged cult of personality around Musk.


People excited about space ships

> dangerous cult of personality surrounding Musk


I don't think this in particular is a personality cult, but it is pretty obvious people are kept around and probably encouraged to cheer and shit like it's a sporting event. It's a bit awkward and wouldn't surprise me that the awkward suggestion came from the top.

I get occasionally getting excited but this feels forced and doesn't it happen on every launch?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: