Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> the Soviets had a moral obligation to right some of those wrongs.

That is extremely naive indeed to think that Stalin would have any moral obligations to right any of his perceived wrongs.

All the trajectory of his political life suggested he will shoot the survivors, so to say.



> extremely naive

How exactly? Believing that he had that obligation doesn’t mean that I also believe that he could have acted on in under any set of circumstances.


I may be beliving that a benevolent AI has an obligation preserve our consciousness after our death, as well as treat us with free ice cream. There should be a process of reconciling your beliefs with reality.

Poland did end up on the receiving side of Stalin's benevolent dictatorship. He essentially de-partitioned Poland thus effectively recreating it. An uncelebrated founding father of Polish nation state.

Many people would think Poles suffered comparatively little and got out with comparatively much out of WW2.


This is 1984 level of bullshit. "War is peace, murdering innocent people and annexing countries is benevolent".

> [Stalin] essentially de-partitioned Poland

Are you even aware that Poland existed before WW2? There was no need to "de-" partition it if you just kept your hands to yourself. It was Hitler and Stalin who partitioned it in the first place.

And even in strictly technical terms - Poland was in one piece after 1941 because Germans took it over from soviets. There was no need to "de-partition" it after WW2 either.

On the other hand soviets did partition it AGAIN in 1945 by splitting the eastern parts and annexing them to USSR. Even including the gains in the west - Poland lost about 1/7th of its territory during WW2 because soviets just took it.

> Many people would think Poles suffered comparatively little and got out with comparatively much out of WW2.

Over 1/6th of Polish population died in WW2. About 6 million Polish citizens (half of them Polish Jews) died because Nazi Germany and Soviet Union joined forces to invade Poland in 1939 and did ethnic cleansings and political repressions there. Germans for 5 years, Russians for 50 years.

Stalin is personally responsible for ordering murder of several hundreds thousands of Poles and forced expulsion of millions of Poles from their homes in eastern Poland (which became USSR after WW2). And indirectly co-responsible for all the deaths that resulted from WW2 which he helped Hitler start.

> An uncelebrated founding father of Polish nation state.

Fuck you.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: