Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Is this a real risk these days? I am interested (given I do use Cloudflare’s registrar and DNS (integrates nicely with IaC).


A mini horror story related to this just last year.

When I deleted the cloudflare DNS for one of my domains I also completely lost access to the cloudflare registrar for that domain.

Even though they should not be coupled at all and the UI makes it very much appear like they are decoupled.

I imagine this is a bug that's been fixed by now but it was still super panic inducing in the moment.

So ya keep those DNS and domains separate if possible.


Not sure, honestly.


Interesting! also asked Claude Opus:

Using the same provider for both domain registration and DNS hosting can introduce several risks. Here are some of the main risks and ways to mitigate them:

1. Single point of failure: If the provider experiences an outage or security breach, both your domain registration and DNS hosting could be affected simultaneously. This can cause your website or services to become unavailable. Mitigation: Consider using separate providers for domain registration and DNS hosting to reduce the impact of a single provider's issues.

2. Provider lock-in: Some providers make it difficult to transfer your domain or DNS management to another provider, leaving you dependent on their services. Mitigation: Choose a provider that allows easy domain transfers and supports standard DNS management protocols like EPP (Extensible Provisioning Protocol). Familiarize yourself with the transfer process before committing to a provider.

3. Security vulnerabilities: If the provider's security measures are inadequate, attackers may be able to gain unauthorized access to your domain and DNS settings, potentially leading to domain hijacking or DNS tampering. Mitigation: Select a reputable provider with strong security practices, such as two-factor authentication, IP restrictions, and regular security audits. Enable additional security features like DNSSEC (Domain Name System Security Extensions) to protect against DNS spoofing.

4. Lack of redundancy: Relying on a single provider for both domain registration and DNS hosting means you don't have a backup if that provider experiences issues. Mitigation: Consider using secondary DNS services from a different provider to ensure redundancy and failover capabilities.

5. Limited control and flexibility: Some providers may offer limited control over your DNS settings or have restrictions on the types of records you can configure. Mitigation: Opt for a provider that offers a comprehensive and user-friendly DNS management interface with support for various record types and advanced features like GeoDNS or failover.

To further mitigate risks, consider the following best practices:

1. Keep your domain registration and DNS hosting accounts secure with strong, unique passwords and enable two-factor authentication.

2. Regularly monitor your domain and DNS settings for any unauthorized changes.

3. Keep your contact information up to date with your domain registrar to ensure you receive important notifications and can respond promptly to any issues.

4. Familiarize yourself with the domain transfer process and keep backups of your DNS configuration to ease migration to another provider if needed.

5. Choose reputable providers with a track record of reliability, security, and customer support.

By being aware of these risks and implementing appropriate mitigation measures, you can minimize the potential impact of using the same provider for domain registration and DNS hosting.


Those are valid. I would personally be worried about getting kicked off Cloudflare and the procedure for transferring domains being messy and time consuming.

(Although CF seems perfectly happy hosting really shady sites that host primarily illegal content)


I asked Perplexity: Using the same provider for both domain registration and DNS hosting can present several risks. Here are the primary risks and ways to mitigate or prevent them:

## Risks

1. *Single Point of Failure*: - If the provider experiences an outage, both your domain registration and DNS services could be affected, leading to downtime for your website and email services[2].

2. *Security Vulnerabilities*: - Using a single provider increases the risk of DNS hijacking, DNS cache poisoning, and other DNS attacks if the provider's security is compromised[3][4].

3. *Limited DNS Features*: - Some domain registrars that offer DNS services may not provide advanced DNS features like DNSSEC, Anycast, or DDoS protection, which are crucial for security and performance[2][5].

4. *Vendor Lock-in*: - It may be more challenging to transfer your domain or DNS services to another provider if both are managed by the same company, potentially leading to higher costs or service disruptions[1].

## Mitigation Strategies

1. *Use DNSSEC*: - Implement DNSSEC (Domain Name System Security Extensions) to protect against DNS hijacking and cache poisoning. DNSSEC adds a layer of security by enabling DNS responses to be verified using digital signatures[3][4].

2. *Redundancy and Backup*: - Use secondary DNS providers to ensure redundancy. This way, if your primary DNS provider experiences an outage, the secondary provider can handle DNS queries, minimizing downtime[2][5].

3. *Choose a Reputable Provider*: - Select a provider that specializes in DNS services and offers robust security features, including DDoS mitigation, Anycast networks, and DNSSEC. This ensures that you are using the latest DNS technologies and security measures[2][7].

4. *Regular Security Audits*: - Conduct regular security audits of your DNS configurations and keep your DNS software updated to protect against vulnerabilities and exploits[7].

5. *Enable Two-Factor Authentication (2FA)*: - Use 2FA for accessing your domain and DNS management interfaces to prevent unauthorized access. Additionally, consider IP whitelisting to restrict access to trusted IP addresses only[3][5].

6. *Client Lock*: - Utilize client lock features provided by your registrar to prevent unauthorized changes to your DNS records without approval from a specific individual within your organization[3][5].

By implementing these strategies, you can significantly reduce the risks associated with using the same provider for domain registration and DNS hosting, ensuring better security, reliability, and performance for your online services.

Sources [1] Everything About Website Domain Registration : Best Practices And ... https://monsterhost.com/everything-about-website-domain-regi... [2] Should you keep your DNS management and domain registration ... https://blog.dnsimple.com/2015/03/benefits-and-drawbacks-of-... [3] What is DNS Hijacking and Mitigation Methods - GlobalDots https://www.globaldots.com/resources/blog/what-is-dns-hijack... [4] DNS Attacks: Tutorial & Prevention Best Practices - Catchpoint https://www.catchpoint.com/dns-monitoring/dns-attack [5] How to Prevent DNS Attacks: DNS Security Best Practices https://www.esecurityplanet.com/networks/how-to-prevent-dns-... [6] Unraveling the roles of domain registrars and web hosting providers https://www.godaddy.com/resources/skills/roles-of-domain-reg... [7] Top Five DNS Security Attack Risks and How to Avoid Them | Blog https://www.humanize.security/blog/cyber-awareness/top-five-...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: