Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> claim that the relative failure of the California High-Speed Rail “boondoggle” represents the political dysfunction of either California

> This criticism also misunderstands one of the main challenges that CAHSR has faced. Al Boraq had full funding lined up before the project began. CAHSR did not. This led to delays that reduced support and encouraged critics, which starved it of funding commitments and thus led to further delays. California undermined CAHSR from the start.

That just sounds like describing dysfunctional government using more words. Either the government can get it done or they can’t. Allowing endless vetos and delays to gum up the process is a political decision.



I think the argument is that the real issue is political will and not structural issues in government.

Personally, it seems fair to call that political dysfunction too, but it’s reasonable to try and make the distinction.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: