Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

in fact value is created in every transaction: someone sells something for more money than it's worth to them and someone buys the thing for less money than the thing is worth to them (otherwise the transaction would not occur)


> value is created in every transaction

Lots of transactions actually destroy value, they just do so in a way that externalizes this cost.

A good example is advertising: companies are incentivized to dump all available resources into marketing, because those who don't get out-competed by those who do. It is a winner-takes-all game where the strategy that maximizes global value is nowhere close to being a Nash equilibrium.

A more extreme example would be hiring someone to go rob a bank. No value is created (lots is destroyed) but both parties to the transaction come out ahead.


> otherwise the transaction would not occur

Doesn't this assume perfect information?


no, how is that relevant? someone has something to sell for $1 that you value more than the $1 in your pocket so you buy it; doesn't matter if someone a block away is selling it for $0.50


A perception of value depends on an assessment, which requires information. Suppose the thing you thought would provide $1 of value doesn't actually.

Edit: concrete example. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lemon_(automobile)

Edit2: metaphorical example. I have a very valuable bridge to sell you. Just hope the value you receive isn't different than the value you perceive at transaction time. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/I_have_a_bridge_to_sell_you


NFTs broke this.


no they didn't




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: