There is a definitely a phenomenon visible to anyone who has hired self-taught gunslingers versus companies stocked with highly educated CS grads. Part of it, I think, comes down to motivation and [needing to prove] self-worth when solving problems. This isn't just a phenomenon in code. My grandfather was a solo contractor, my dad was a solo lawyer (the first to graduate college in my family), I'm a solo and self-taught coder, 25 years in the industry (and the only of 4 brothers not to graduate college). There's a personality type that needs to prove something to themselves, has trouble with authority, isn't much of a team player, and never throws their hands up in defeat when faced with a challenge.
But I'd like to add that that's not really why I do this job. I do it because I find it vastly entertaining. Maybe you're right that CS grads are averse to unknown areas, and work better as team players ("cogs" is a bit harsh), and it's true that autodidacts try to save ourselves time instead of doing things twice. Sure, I hate boilerplate and drudgery. But for me the thing is, I love when I get a fresh problem to solve, that causes me to learn new techniques along the way. That's what makes my work feel like a joy, like a hobby, something I'm excited to wake up and do, and spend all night teasing out. And because of that, I self-select for the jobs that will give me that feeling, and I turn down the jobs that feel repetitious. After all, I should get something out of it more than money, and I can't sleep on improving my skills, right? So in those tasks, I'm doubly motivated and I'm probably far more productive for that reason than even needing to prove something, or because I'm aware that I'm being relied on as an irreplaceable part.
I guess this is a roundabout way of saying that once you decide to drop out, go independent, and live a certain way, the stakes are a lot higher, and the people who make it in that arena are people who will always put in a lot more effort. Giving up the 9-5 didn't mean I started choosing my own hours. It meant I became on-call 24/7 to my clients, for decades. And yet I wouldn't give up the freedom of being able to do that from any country in the world, or being able to choose my own projects and choose how I'd implement new ones. Dirty secret: A lot of times with a new project, I know how to do it with an existing technology, but I use it as an excuse to learn something completely new and implement it in a way I never would have. I don't charge extra time for my learning or trial and error, but I consider it a gift that I have the freedom to do that while I work.
But I'd like to add that that's not really why I do this job. I do it because I find it vastly entertaining. Maybe you're right that CS grads are averse to unknown areas, and work better as team players ("cogs" is a bit harsh), and it's true that autodidacts try to save ourselves time instead of doing things twice. Sure, I hate boilerplate and drudgery. But for me the thing is, I love when I get a fresh problem to solve, that causes me to learn new techniques along the way. That's what makes my work feel like a joy, like a hobby, something I'm excited to wake up and do, and spend all night teasing out. And because of that, I self-select for the jobs that will give me that feeling, and I turn down the jobs that feel repetitious. After all, I should get something out of it more than money, and I can't sleep on improving my skills, right? So in those tasks, I'm doubly motivated and I'm probably far more productive for that reason than even needing to prove something, or because I'm aware that I'm being relied on as an irreplaceable part.
I guess this is a roundabout way of saying that once you decide to drop out, go independent, and live a certain way, the stakes are a lot higher, and the people who make it in that arena are people who will always put in a lot more effort. Giving up the 9-5 didn't mean I started choosing my own hours. It meant I became on-call 24/7 to my clients, for decades. And yet I wouldn't give up the freedom of being able to do that from any country in the world, or being able to choose my own projects and choose how I'd implement new ones. Dirty secret: A lot of times with a new project, I know how to do it with an existing technology, but I use it as an excuse to learn something completely new and implement it in a way I never would have. I don't charge extra time for my learning or trial and error, but I consider it a gift that I have the freedom to do that while I work.