Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

There are at least five YouTube videos of ATC communications with pilots in trouble because of an IPad failure.


Doesn't surprise me. I got on a flight that had to go back to gate due to an "iPad failure" about 6 years ago. The captain was apologising as we disembarked. I asked him what happened. He said software issue across both their flight plan iPads. Hardware was fine. Not sure if it grounded other flights but we were back on a different plane about 2 hours later.


To be clear, we're actually talking about two separate things, they both just use an iPad.

You're talking about what's known as an electronic flight bag, which is using a tablet as a replacement for paper maps and charts. This is legal and has been for some time.

What I and Animats are talking about is running an app on a ipad as a "replacement" for equipment or training that is required for safe, legal, operation. NOT legal.


Yes. Two examples: [1][2] More can be found with Google.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t1E7rGCdZMI

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SMxsdEeEzFM


Oh hell why would you use an iPad for that. As a convenience yes but not a substitute for proper instruments and procedure.


Maybe because the iPad has a more user-friendly interface than most avionics.

Here's the cockpit of the Gripen, Saab's current fighter aircraft.[1] One big screen across the whole panel. No sign of a classic altimeter or compass. There's a HUD as well, so there's a second device for the basic flight instruments.

[1] https://bestfighter4canada.blogspot.com/p/the-saab-gripen-do...


The interface is another story. I’m considering the engineering, software quality snd reliability.


Does this result in a “you get to live but you’re never allowed to fly a plane again” situation?


The worst typical outcome for pilots who get these violations is taking training, getting signed off to that effect, and a “709 ride” to get their certificate back. They might also face a short suspension.

Very few pilots manage to earn a lifetime ban.


There's actually a self-report line (run by NASA, no less) where pilots can report stuff like this.

It's really quite brilliant.

The way that you get pilots to do it is that if you drop the dime on yourself it actually gives you virtual immunity from consequences, as long as no injuries or serious damage actually occurred. The idea is to actually find systemic process/procedure issues.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: