Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I think it's pretty easy to make an argument against URL shorteners, but I think it's a bit harder to defend killing existing short links. Stop new links from being minted, keep up a "Report Abuse" page, maybe even scan the existing DB for Google Login look-alikes. The upkeep is as much or less than responsibly running a URL short link site in the first place.

Instead, they're just disappearing _all_* goo.gl short links. The overwhelming majority of which are benign links made by users who were promised a super stable URL link shortening service backed by the Google brand.

*edit: Not all, but nearly.



Not all.

> All other [active] goo.gl links will be preserved and will continue to function as normal. To check if your link will be retained, visit the link today. If your link redirects you without a message, it will continue to work.

https://developers.googleblog.com/en/google-url-shortener-li...


This is true. An enormous number links are going to die, however.


> Stop new links from being minted

They already did this in 2019.

The service has been deprecated for a very long time.

> Instead, they're just disappearing _all_ goo.gl short links

This is false. They are sunsetting inactive links.


I know its been deprecated. I'm just saying that they could have stopped it there.

It is true that it is not _all_ links, apologies. "Inactive" here is defined as "not visited in 2024" which is a crazy small envelope. I wouldn't be surprised if nearly all links were deleted.


They were going to shut down the service entirely until a public outcry.


> They are sunsetting inactive links.

...which is even harder to justify than removing them all.


I guess there's a tiny chance they'll learn to A: not trust google to keep anything alive, or B: not use link shorteners?


Most of the time it's not the people who created the link who are going be annoyed with the broken link...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: