Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

AFAIK bluesky isn't even properly federated yet, everything relies on a single "BGS" router server.


This is misleading. I’m not sure if you’ve read the article so it’s difficult to elaborate — it aims to explain precisely that.

There isn’t such a thing as “Bluesky getting federated” — that doesn’t on its own mean anything. In Mastodon world, “getting federated” means many copies of the same webapp emailing each other. In atproto, you don’t create many copies of the same app. Instead, it’s shaped like the web — individual users can host their data in different places, and apps aggregate over that data. There’s no point in having many copies of the same app.

The BGS server you’re referring to is the “relay” mentioned in the article. Running your own relay is possible (Blacksky does it, as mentioned in the article). It costs about $30/mo with the current traffic. However, note that a relay is very dumb (it’s just a retransmitter of signed JSON over websocket). It’s cool that anyone can run one but by itself this isn’t a vanity metric to chase. We’ll probably see more independent relays but usually someone would run one for a reason — to insulate a company or a community from upstream failures, or maybe to censor things (in repressive governments).


Not true, there are many independent relays (one went online today, in fact: https://bsky.app/profile/upcloud.com/post/3lzqkrrqap22n).

This also completely misunderstands the architecture. Things don't hinge on the relays at all and they don't act as routers.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: