Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Times are changing. The pendulum swing back from MAGA is going to be interesting.


Hopefully we don't add too much energy to the pendulum because eventually it will swing back again


> Times are changing. The pendulum swing back from MAGA is going to be interesting

The pendelum swings in multiple dimensions. MAGA went mainstream in a way the Tea Party and conservativism did not by abandoning policy purity in favour of, first, messaging, and later, idolatry.

The preserved component between MAGA's messaging and Mamdani's rise is populism and, to a lesser degree, divisive politics. Where MAGA failed and Mamdani may deliver is in pragmatism (and not being corrupt).

There is an opportunity to unify "abundance" policies with inclusive progressivism or villanisation of wealth. (I'm not convinced you can do both. If you want to pursue growth and cost of living, you need to turn the capital spigots. Accumulated capital facilitates that. If you want to tackle inequality and billionaires, you'll need to temporarily destabilise those capital structures. You'll also, presumably, be increasing the lower and middle classes' purchasing power, which limits how much public spending you can do without spiking inflation.)

San Francisco progressives can influence national politics. But anyone insisting on copy-paste purism is a godsend to MAGA.


Main reason why MAGA will fail even harder is that you now see that there is basically nothing holding this movement together apart from Trump.

Next step in MAGA is the open inheritance war between the original 2016 spirit and the 2024 donor class.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: