Haskell’s fromJust, and similar partial functions like head, are as dangerous as Rust’s unwrap. The difference is only in the failure mode. Rust panics, whereas Haskell throws a runtime exception.
You might think that the Haskell behavior is “safer” in some sense, but there’s a huge gotcha: exceptions in pure code are the mortal enemy of lazy evaluation. Lazy evaluation means that an exception can occur after the catch block that surrounded the code in question has exited, so the exception isn’t guaranteed to get caught.
Exceptions can be ok in a monad like IO, which is what they’re intended for - the monad enforces an evaluation order. But if you use a partial function like fromJust in pure code, you have to be very careful about forcing evaluation if you want to be able to catch the exception it might generate. That’s antithetical to the goal of using exceptions - now you have to write to code carefully to make sure exceptions are catchable.
The bottom line is that for reliable code, you need to avoid fromJust and friends in Haskell as much you do in Rust.
The solution in both languages is to use a linter to warn about the use of partial functions: HLint for Haskell, Clippy for Rust. If Cloudflare had done that - and paid attention to the warning! - they would have caught that unwrap error of theirs at linting time. This is basically a learning curve issue.
I forgot about fromJust. On the other hand, fromJust is shunned by practically everybody writing Haskell. `unwrap` doesn't have the same status. I also understand why. Rust wanted to be more appealing, not too restrictive while Haskell doesn't care about attracting developers.
You might think that the Haskell behavior is “safer” in some sense, but there’s a huge gotcha: exceptions in pure code are the mortal enemy of lazy evaluation. Lazy evaluation means that an exception can occur after the catch block that surrounded the code in question has exited, so the exception isn’t guaranteed to get caught.
Exceptions can be ok in a monad like IO, which is what they’re intended for - the monad enforces an evaluation order. But if you use a partial function like fromJust in pure code, you have to be very careful about forcing evaluation if you want to be able to catch the exception it might generate. That’s antithetical to the goal of using exceptions - now you have to write to code carefully to make sure exceptions are catchable.
The bottom line is that for reliable code, you need to avoid fromJust and friends in Haskell as much you do in Rust.
The solution in both languages is to use a linter to warn about the use of partial functions: HLint for Haskell, Clippy for Rust. If Cloudflare had done that - and paid attention to the warning! - they would have caught that unwrap error of theirs at linting time. This is basically a learning curve issue.