Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> I'm not making a judgment about this person [...] just stating a reasonable conclusion that the author suffered from mental illness.

You're not making a judgment, but are somehow able to diagnose mental illness from a blog post? Wild.

It's far easier to conclude that the system has failed this person, as it habitually fails millions of people in the US, in these same circumstances. Are they all mentally ill?

And even if mental health is an issue, does that mean that they are somehow less worthy of assistance? That it's OK for a human being to live under a bridge?

The level of self-righteousness and lack of empathy in your comments is baffling.



> You're not making a judgment, but are somehow able to diagnose mental illness from a blog post? Wild.

The author literally talks about his "psychosis" that led him to his predicament, so no, I don't think it's a judgment, just the ability to read.

> And even if mental health is an issue, does that mean that they are somehow less worthy of assistance?

I have no idea where you seem to get this idea. My point is that, at least in this author's case, he has received assistance. He discusses 2 separate instances in this post where he declined resources and support - he is living under a bridge because he specifically rejected the shelter that was offered him.

Could the process of getting people support be better? Of course, but his experience dealing with the pains of bureaucracy doesn't seem much different that bureaucratic slights we all, rich and poor, have to deal with when trying to get assistance from government. FWIW I especially liked his "I identify as a woman" comment in order to get a shower.

> The level of self-righteousness and lack of empathy in your comments is baffling.

The only self righteousness I see on display is your belief that everyone else is so uncaring because we don't necessarily think the government should force this person into a shelter. I'm not judging the author at all, but I'm certainly judging you.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: