Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

How is the waste radioactive? Doesn't that mean that the original materials were also radioactive?


> Rare earths always occur alongside the radioactive elements thorium and uranium, and safely separating them is a complex process.

http://www.motherjones.com/documents/463290-ntn-lynas-report


When you mine rare earths, you often get Thorium.


OK I guess my question is, how does processing make the radiation more dangerous? Can't they, I don't know, put the material back near where they found it?


Radioacitivy in the ore is dilute, but during processing there is a step where you separate the daughter nuclides from thorium decay, mainly radium-228. Those wastes have real danger potential.


It's a question of exposure. When the material is encased in solid rock hundreds, if not thousands of feet blow, the exposure risk is very low.

Once you pull it out of the ground - exposure becomes a real problem. They mention that some of the materials must be kept in liquid, so it does not become a dust that can get blown away. At the same time, they need to line the storage pool with a material that will block it from seeping into the groundwater. For centuries.


> At the same time, they need to line the storage pool with a material that will block it from seeping into the groundwater. For centuries.

Not for thorium. The stuff is almost harmless, and is insoluble in water, so tends to just stay put.

Plus, even if you did have to isolate it, centuries would be nothing. It's has a half life of 14 billion years! Just bury it back in the ground and that's all - it's really not very radioactive. (Just deep enough that it won't be dug up by accident and that's all - you don't need to block the radioactivity, since even a piece of paper is enough shielding.)

A little knowledge is a dangerous thing since you are confusing cesium from nuclear reactors and thorium.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: