Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> The whole sharing economy thing is unsafe, ridiculous, and kind of pathetic.

How do New Yorkers win by having less choice?



Their neighbours are more likely to be people there for the long term and with an interest in the community, rather than just renting out their place to people a night at a time.

I can see the negative side of AirBnB, though that said I just booked a place in Paris because every central hotel under $300/night appears to be booked for next week.


Do you not worry that someone will setup cameras in the WC, record you pooping, then sell the videos, together with your personal details, on an underground tor darksite in exchange for Bitcoins? And you'll never know?

I used to be very trusting of places until I stayed at a university accom during a conference one time. The janitor was up to no good, but we had to leave and no one wanted the trouble of reporting it to front desk.


I've stayed in tiny hotels in 30+ countries and not been worried about that so I'm not sure why it would be much different with AirBnB.


> Their neighbours are more likely to be people there for the long term and with an interest in the community, rather than just renting out their place to people a night at a time.

Of course that is true, but no they can no longer choose to live in places that allow AirBnBing their apartments. Your argument seems more applicable w/r/t contract law. If you don't want those kind of neighbors you can live in places that prohibit AirBnB.


Most places do prohibit AirBnB-style arrangements in many circumstances. A lot of landlords prohibit it in their contracts.


I am a New Yorker and I win by not having someone here for the short term vs an actual neighbor. This is a hotel no matter which way you try and paint it.


Can't you get the same thing by choosing to live somewhere that contractually prevents AirBnB rather than prohibiting it for everyone?

> This is a hotel no matter which way you try and paint it.

How is renting out your apartment 3 weekends a year a hotel? You can currently do that on craigslist, it's just harder to connect buyers and sellers.


They don't have less choice, they might even have more choice because flat which has been used as hotels could become flats again.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: