Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin



Which apparently has been flagged off of the front page.


I'm getting tired of the knee-jerk tendency for a small group of people to flag these extremely critical revelations. Yesterday the post about the mass rally on Washington was flagged to the bottom and eventually kicked off the front page. A recent poll revealed overwhelming support for more, not less reports on these spying stories, and yet a vocal minority is able to disregard the community's wishes and ruin things for everyone.

I don't know how this can be solved other than perhaps intense moderation to unflag everything regarding these revelations and let their popularity be determined solely by votes.


This place is only incidentally run as a semi-democracy. The goal is not to get the stuff on the front page that the most people want but the stuff that satisfy peoples intellectual curiosity.

If you want a completely democratically run internet forum, create your own subreddit or on www.reddit.com.

Incidentally Hacker News was made partially as a response to the decline of the general reddit communities and with the hope of addressing at least some of their failures - such as relying too much on democracy.


I'm getting tired of the knee-jerk tendency for a small group of people to flag these extremely critical revelations.

The "knee-jerk" comes from the tendency of people to submit lots and lots of less important stories on the same handful of topics, rather than a few good ones. Remember when the front page was nothing but Erlang? Or nothing but Steve Jobs eulogies? For people that come for quality rather than quantity, it harms the signal to noise ratio. Submitting even more just exacerbates the problem, without creating better discussions (more threads != better threads) in exchange.

As tomjen3 suggests: find or create your own subreddit. Subreddits themselves exist because this same problem afflicted Reddit.

Edit: I'm sorry if I offended somebody. I'm simply trying to propose a solution for people that feel they aren't seeing the stories they want to see on HN.


So you could call this a "false flag" operation?


Any idea why it'd be flagged?


People perhaps fatigued by constant spying mini-revelations


"mini" revelations ... if you're an American.

Unbelievable. When it's the NSA spying on US citizens, everybody's paying attention, and US people scramble to point out that the EU isn't much better, either (which we knew already because it wasn't kept secret from us in the first place. blame us for the apathy, I applaud the US's (relative) outrage). And then something like this comes out, the UK hacking a neighbour EU country, and people are suddenly "huh we're tired of this news". Self-centred is more what I'd call it.


"mini" is certainly not the right word to use if the provider in question "hosts many of the most important European Union institutions, universities and corporations, as well as NATO."




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: