Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

"I made the perfect accessory, but it only works with electric cars. GM abused their car monopoly to make gas engines, not electric engines, costing me money.

GM owes us all money. GM must be stopped, and GM must pay."

(I'll also note that you didn't give Microsoft any money when IE helped you make money, and they're not your insurance policy when you don't make money, either.)



> "IE helped you make money"

If IE6 hadn't existed then we would have had Op., Konq, FF, Saf and been able to move onto use PNG about 8 years earlier, the agreed box model for CSS, less screwy flash implementation, etc.. In addition we'd probably have moved on a lot more with SVG and XHTML would have been accepted by all browsers so we wouldn't be moving backwards from XML to less a consistent SGML-like HTML. We'd have been able to use opacity earlier. Web designers would have been able to concentrate on extended functionality and graceful design rather that how messed up IE was. Websites would have cost 20%+ less to make.

How the heck has IE helped make web designers / devs money? That's like saying having a leg amputation helped to make you more mobile.


Without standing very firmly behind the argument, Microsoft popularized computers in a serious way that provided the market that provided web jobs. You can argue that without Microsoft, the collection of marginal suppliers would have stepped up and provided the same large market, but you can't show that very well.

(Another argument suggests that the automatically provided browser enhanced the interest in the internet - "I have this program that doesn't work! I must make it work by getting the internet!" - that may not have existed without IE preinstalled. "If the internet is so useful, why didn't it come preinstalled, like Office did?")


I guess then AOL helped me to make money too. Time Berners-Lee helped me to make money. Wife beating helped me to make money (one of my clients is a womens' aid group). Bit obtuse.


GM doesn't have a car monopoly. The monopoly is why what I said makes sense, and what you said does not.


CD-Rs have no monopoly, and yet, there are blank media levies in many countries.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_copying_levy


You failed to convey a point.


You suggest a monopoly is the requirement to subsidize other industries. I display an extant case of a non-monopoly subsidizing an industry.


I made no such suggestion.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: