Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Thanks for your kind words. It took me a long while before hitting that submit button. It's that moment when you're unsure if what you've written is any good.


I found myself actually wanting the watch reading this, which caught me off guard. Really well done.


I think I now know why. There was a TED talk by Simon Sinek regarding how Apple sells its products to its customers by making you believe why you should need one than without one.

http://www.ted.com/talks/simon_sinek_how_great_leaders_inspi...

The keynote didn't really sell me the watch. To me it was more like a 'me too' smartwatch but with several customizable options to set it apart from the competition. They should've stick with one model and iterate later like they always did.

But I agree, if the presentation was worded like this, I probably would've bought one in a whim and wouldn't think the heartbeat thing as gimmicky.


You did a great job of taking the "feeling overwhelmed by possible choices" out and putting a lot of "Steve Jobs" in. Good work!


I think you know what you wrote was done well.

While I don't think so much should be viewed under the 'what would Jobs do' prism, I agreed with your points on product development, choice, and presentation. Brilliantly written.


I think it was spot on. It made me yearn for Steve and his keynotes. It's sad that he's gone and we'll never see the likes of him again I fear.


I'll be downvoted for this, but I'd like the chance to express myself to the author.

I felt what you wrote was in poor taste. I think that it's in poor taste to speak for the dead when one was close friends with them, and I think that it's worse still to speak for a celebrity whom you had no personal acquaintance with.

I feel like you did nothing more than mask your own personal complaints about Apple inside dialog written as if spoken by Jobs' , but with little forethought about Jobs' past history of actions, or the hierarchy of team effort that goes on at Apple, or even the way Jobs presented himself.

The disparaging comments about 'his' previous lineup that 'he' (you) made proved that furthermore.

I say all this with a personal hatred for Apple and the Steve Jobs method of getting stuff done, so I'd hate for anyone to think that i'm simply upset that it is sullying His name. I don't care about that; I just don't think that it's realistic in the least.


What you did there is... quite something, and not trivial at all.

Make sure you don't overlook whichever part of the brain or thinking framework/state that allowed you to pull that off.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: