Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You are mistaken.

Applying for the green card lottery does nothing to hurt any current or future visa applications you make. Visas with a nonimmigrant intent will ask questions like:

"Do you have a current I-485 application in process?"

"Have you previously applied for an I-485?"

"Have you been rejected for an I-485?"

For those that don't know, an I-485 is an AoS (adjustment of status) application.

You can truthfully answer "no" to all of these questions because an I-485 is something very specific and entering the DV lottery is not that.

So you have to be really careful about what is said (eg nonimmigrant intent for a visa) and what are the actual rules. If the form simply asks about I-485 applications, you can truthfully answer "no" even if you want to stay here forever.

By the time you get to filing an I-485 you're basically done with a PR application. You're just waiting for it to come through. It may take 6 months or 12 months but it won't randomly take years (like a Labor Certification can).

Now as far as work visas go, the H1B allows an immigrant intent so none of this is an issue.

For visas that don't (eg Canadian TN, Australian E3), even there the rules are murky. USCIS says that, for example, filing an I-485 shows immigrant intent but they've also issued a ruling saying that filing an I-485 can't solely be used to deny a renewal or the issuing of those visas. So what does that mean in practice? Well, nobody really knows.

That too is a problem.

But I digress...

My main point is you are 100% incorrect when you say applying for the DV lottery impacts your ability to apply for a nonimmigrant visa in any way. It does not.



None of the forms I filled in asked about I-485, they asked "Has anyone ever filed an immigration petition on your behalf?", which I had to answer yes to because my aunt at one point started sponsoring my mom for a sibling green card - even though that application was filed before I was born, and was abandoned decades ago.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: